Wednesday, September 26, 2007

Autumn Winds of a Changing Market

As I mentioned on Aug 22, one of the greatest benefits of the CCIM network is the network of professionals we have in this industry, and their tireless assistance in providing expert market research for many of our posts. Last evening I received a detailed report on the effects of the "credit crunch" on the commercial markets and the implications of these changes as we move forward. Thanks again to Jim Nowak, CCIM from San Clemente, CA with Site Systems, Inc. for the information. I've asked Jim (as well as any other CCIM) to be a guest contributor to our forum.

Due to liquidity and valuation issues surrounding securitized debt backed by sub prime mortgages in the US home market, an increased perception of risk on the part of lenders has spread throughout the global financial system creating the current “Credit Crunch.”

Below are ten of the possible implications for the commercial real estate sector.

  1. Sales volume will drop until a new price level is achieved and friction between sellers and buyers eases. Implication: Falling volume will result in less 1031 demand. Demand for 1031 properties will also soften as the gains on sales drop and more capital is reinvested into alternate asset classes.
  2. A flight to quality is typically experienced during any period of market uncertainty. Implication: Top assets in top markets will see less of a price correction than class B & C assets in secondary and tertiary markets.
  3. Properties and markets that command the attention of institutional and foreign buyers will continue to have the most competitive bidding. Markets with buyers that have relied most on CMBS conduit financing will see investor demand fall. Implication: Top assets in top markets will see less of a price correction than class B & C assets in secondary and tertiary markets.
  4. Mega-deals and portfolio transactions have been primarily financed by Wall Street will be curtailed due to the credit crunch. Implication: Pricing premium enjoyed for portfolios and other major asset sales will diminish.
  5. Portfolio Lenders are regaining market share from conduits. For these lenders, sponsorship matters and a track record and proven operating abilities are highly preferred. Implications: Sellers won’t see as many new, out-of-state bidders. It discourages new investors plus some portfolio lenders do not like TICs or other complicated ownership structures.
  6. With the amount of busted deals and re-trading that has occurred lately, sellers are favoring buyers with a high confidence of closing. Implication: The highest bid may no longer win the deal. Sellers are favoring buyers with no financing contingencies and ones that can quickly make firm and non-refundable deposits. Institutions and other established, reputable buyers will be favored.
  7. In the past, a 90- 95% leased building achieved prices close to that of fully leased buildings. Now buyers will have to put more equity at risk since their lender won’t give them credit for vacant space anymore. Implication: Prices for well leased properties will hold up well compared to those with current vacancy or heavy rollover exposure.
  8. Just as construction costs were starting to stabilize and commercial development was gearing up, the credit markets have changed the economics again. Developers are facing higher financing costs and greater equity contributions even if they can get a loan. Implication: New development will remain constrained which is a positive for the space markets. Of all the uncertainties in the market, the fear of overbuilding is not one.
  9. Demand for mezzanine debt has grown as LTVs of first mortgages have fallen. With a number of mezz lenders clipped by the credit crunch, mezzanine debt has been significantly re-priced with returns back in the mid to high teens. Implication: Yields on mezz debt are looking attractive compared to equity, and more private equity funds are contemplating filling this capital void.
  10. As new mortgages are tough to get and terms are not as favorable, assumable debt will be sought by buyers. Implication: Properties with mortgages originated over the past few years that are also assumable will trade at a premium. Institutions may find opportunities in assuming moderate leverage with mortgage rates that are now relatively low.

- from Real Capital Analytics September Report (Phone: 866-REAL DATA)


Anonymous said...

These articles are fantastic; the information you show us is interesting for everybody and is really good written. It’s just great!! Do you want to know something more? Read it...: Great investment opportunity in Costa Rica: jaco beach real estate, map jaco beach, hotel in jaco beach costa rica. Visit us for more info at:

Sean M. Broderick, CCIM said...

Thank you for the nice words. I'll check it out.